NEWSLETTER | ISSUE 6 | ISLA FEATURE

Countering Anti-Rights Actors

October 2026

By Domingas Sande

Learning from Poland: What Anti-Rights Mobilisation Means for Africa

One of the most important lessons from Poland is that rights regression does not always present itself as opposition to human rights. Increasingly, it can also be advanced by claiming to defend them.

This was at the heart of ISLA’s learning from Poland webinar, which brought together experiences from Poland and Africa to examine how anti-rights mobilisation operates through law, institutions and public discourse. The discussion did not suggest that Poland offers a ready-made template for Africa. Contexts are different. It did, however, reveal recurring patterns that African human rights movements should be able to recognise when they appear in our own contexts.

Anti-rights actors do not necessarily present themselves as opponents of human rights. They may speak instead about protecting life, family, freedom, religion, parental authority or national sovereignty. These positions can then be translated into constitutional arguments, legal submissions, policy proposals and claims framed in the language of equality, discrimination and fundamental rights. The result is a contest not simply over whether human rights matter, but over how rights are interpreted, whose interests are placed at the centre, and what happens when one set of rights is framed against another.

The webinar also showed how these strategies can work in practice. Drawing on the Polish experience, panellists described how anti-rights actors may use court cases, complaints, administrative processes and legislative proposals to advance particular arguments across legal and political spaces. Their influence does not always depend on winning a case or changing the law. These actions can still create uncertainty, consume the time and resources of activists and shape public debate. A legislative proposal, for example, can influence the conversation even if it never becomes law. This means that the impact of anti-rights legal mobilisation cannot be measured only by the cases won or the laws adopted.

For Africa, this matters because these strategies are not confined to national borders. The discussion pointed to an interconnected ecosystem in which similar narratives and strategies move through conferences, legal networks, faith-based spaces, policy processes, media and international institutions. Materials produced in one setting can travel into another, be adapted into declarations, charters or policy language, and then reappear through local actors.

This transnational dimension is becoming increasingly tangible on the continent, including through the presence of European anti-rights actors in Arusha. The location is particularly significant. As the seat of the African Court on Human and Peoples’ Rights, Arusha places these actors in close proximity to one of the continent’s key human rights institutions, underscoring the need to pay attention not only to the narratives these actors advance, but also to the institutions and spaces in which they are positioning themselves.

The Draft African Charter on Family, Sovereignty and Values was raised during the webinar within this broader discussion as an example of why these competing interpretations of human rights deserve close attention in the African context. The question is not simply whether familiar concepts such as family, sovereignty, or rights appear in a legal text, but what meaning they are given, how they relate to existing human rights standards, and what protections may be weakened when those concepts are redefined.

The webinar also offered an important lesson about how human rights movements can respond. It highlighted the importance of taking anti-rights strategies seriously without giving these actors more influence than they actually have. It also showed how fear of legal action, complaints or other forms of pressure can sometimes lead activists and organisations to become overly cautious or to limit their own work. A stronger response therefore requires looking carefully at the legal arguments being made, identifying where rights language is being distorted, and paying attention to broader patterns when there is evidence that different developments are connected.

If anti-rights mobilisation increasingly operates across borders and institutions, effective responses cannot remain isolated either. The webinar closed with a call for stronger cross-border solidarity, information-sharing and connections between lawyers, activists, researchers and movements. Learning from Poland, then, is not about importing strategies from another context into Africa. It is about recognising patterns, learning from experience and strengthening responses that are firmly grounded in our own contexts.