NEWSLETTER | ISSUE 6 | WHAT’S HAPPENING IN COURTS

What’s Happening in Courts

October 2026

ECOWAS Court Recognises Violence Against Women as a Form of Discrimination

By Winfred Odali and Achieng Orero

In a landmark judgment with significant implications for the protection of women and girls from harmful practices, the ECOWAS Court of Justice has held the Republic of Sierra Leone internationally responsible for failing to take adequate measures to implement, enforce and put in place demonstrable measures to eliminate child marriage as a harmful practice in Sierra Leone.

The judgment, delivered on 25 June 2026 in Adamsay Kabia & Another v. Republic of Sierra Leone, arose from an application brought by Advocaid Limited and child marriage survivor Adamsay Kabia. The applicants argued that Sierra Leone’s failure to adequately prevent and respond to child marriage, despite its widespread prevalence, violated the State’s obligations under regional and international human rights law. The case concerns Adamsay Kabia, who was married at the age of 11 in 2017. In January 2021, she was arrested for the murder of a 3-year-old boy, who was the son of another wife of her husband. The case records that she was aged 15 at the time of her arrest and trial. On 22 April 2021, Adamsay Kabia was convicted of the offence of murder and sentenced to be detained at the Approved School at the pleasure of the President of the Republic of Sierra Leone. The applicants alleged that the State had failed to prevent and adequately respond to child marriage of which Adamsay Kabia was a victim.

The Court found that Sierra Leone had violated its obligations under Articles 1(j), 1(f), 2, 3(4) and 4 of the Protocol to the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights on the Rights of Women in Africa (Maputo Protocol), Articles 2 and 18(3) of the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights, Article 21 of the African Charter on the Rights and Welfare of the Child (ACERWC) and Articles 1, 2, 16(1)(b) and 16 (2) of the Convention on the Elimination of all forms of Discrimination against Women (CEDAW) which require States to take legislative and other measures to eliminate harmful practices affecting women and children.

Three noteworthy issues arise from the decision. Firstly, the Court recognises that Sierra Leone had put in place a Prohibition of Child Marriage Act in 2024. However, the Court is emphatic that the presence of legislation does not discharge the State’s obligations under regional and international law. The State must illustrate sufficiently to the Court every measure that is taken in implementation, enforcement and the demonstrable impact of having the law in place. In order to discharge its duty to respect, protect and fulfil rights, the State must, in line with the CEDAW, ACERWC and Maputo Protocol, take all necessary measures to eliminate harmful practices. The phrase “all necessary measures” can therefore not be limited to legislation or policy. This articulation by the Court is an important milestone in the development of regional standards as it relates to the elimination of violence against women and girls on the continent. States often rely on the enactment of legislation or policy frameworks to establish that they have taken measures to protect women and girls from violence, and yet it has been proven that women and girls remain unsafe from violence in all its forms despite the existence of laws and policies. States must therefore be held to a higher standard as articulated in the Adamsay decision. There must be a verifiable effect of the legislation and policy put in place.

Secondly, the Court conducts a cogent analysis of the due diligence principle. The global recognition of violence against women as a violation of human rights and a form of gender-based discrimination has brought violence against women out of the private zones of silence and placed it firmly in the public sphere of State accountability. This recognition has happened most notably through the evolution of the law of State responsibility under the due diligence principle.  Since the 1988 Velázquez Rodríguez case of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights, which is the landmark decision that clearly set out the due diligence State responsibility for violations of human rights caused by non-State agents, the principle of due diligence has been developed to apply to violence against women. This is critical because the majority of cases of violence are perpetrated by non-state actors. Over the last 3 decades, several International and regional legal frameworks and decisions have recognised that states have a due diligence obligation to address violence against women perpetrated by third parties, or private individuals in the private sphere. The due diligence standard is therefore an important tool for rights holders, giving them power to hold States accountable for gender-based violence against women. In this case, the Court lays out the requisite due diligence standards as they relate to an effective investigation of violence once the State has notice of vulnerability.

Finally, in a considerable departure from its previous decisions, the Court conducts an effective evaluation of freedom from non-discrimination as it relates to violence against women. The ECOWAS Court has previously missed opportunities to develop its own jurisprudence in this regard in alignment with established international frameworks. However, in this instance, a win for women and girls across the continent, the Court finds congruence with the customary international norm that establishes violence as a form of discrimination against women. It is unequivocal in its analysis that child marriage is a manifestation of gender inequality and structural discrimination. The Court reiterates that child marriage is not neutral, is inherently discriminatory, disproportionately affects girls and heightens their vulnerability to domestic violence and maternal mortality. This is significant as this analysis lays the basis for the recognition of the inherent vulnerability of women and girls to violence and removes said violence from the private sphere and places it as the obligation of States to ensure that all forms of violence, whether by state or non-state actors, are prevented and adequately responded to.  This analysis also recognises that violence against women is a structural issue and removes the incidences of violence from the isolated individual and calls for an analysis of the root causes that enable and embed violence against women and, ultimately, State accountability.

The Court concludes that the failure to put in place adequate prohibitions, provide judicial or administrative measures or implement preventive or protective mechanisms is therefore a violation of the right to freedom from gender-based discrimination. This reasoning demonstrates an appreciation for the gravity and systemic nature of violence against women and reinforces the State’s responsibility.

The Court consequently ordered Sierra Leone to review and strengthen legislation criminalising child marriage, adopt appropriate administrative, educational and socio-economic measures aimed at its eradication, and promptly investigate and prosecute the perpetrators in Adamsay’s child marriage. It also awarded her the equivalent of US$10,000 in compensation for the harm suffered.

Beyond Sierra Leone, the judgment offers an important regional precedent. It demonstrates how regional human rights litigation can move beyond individual redress to challenge structural failures that enable gender-based violence, while reaffirming that harmful practices cannot be insulated from human rights scrutiny by their characterisation as tradition or culture.

For lawyers litigating violence against women in Africa, the decision therefore presents an important jurisprudential development: States may be held responsible not only for acts of gender-based violence committed by State actors, but also where failures to prevent, investigate, prosecute, punish and provide effective remedies allow such violence to persist.