NEWSLETTER | ISSUE 6 | WHAT’S HAPPENING IN COURTS
What’s Happening in Courts
October 2026
When the Law Exists but the State Looks Away: A Kenyan Court Rules on the Rights of Migrant Domestic Workers
By Siphokazi Mlindazwe
Every year, tens of thousands of Kenyan women leave home in search of work. Many go to the Middle East, to Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, Iraq, and the UAE to work as domestic workers: cooking, cleaning, raising other people’s children. They go because jobs at home are scarce and wages abroad seem like a lifeline. What too many of them find instead is exploitation, abuse, and a government that has, for too long, simply not shown up.
On 19 June 2026, the Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi delivered a judgment that names this failure plainly. In Legal Advice Centre t/a Kituo Cha Sheria & 13 others v Cabinet Secretary, Ministry of Labour and Social Protection & 7 others (Constitutional Petition No. E038 of 2023), Justice Jemimah Keli found that Kenya had violated the constitutional rights of migrant domestic workers, not because the law was absent, but because the State chose not to enforce it.
ISLA, together with FIDA Kenya, was admitted as joint amici curiae in the proceedings. This newsletter sets out what the case was about, what the court decided, what it means for migrant women workers across Africa, and where the work still needs to go.
The Women Behind the Case
The petition was filed in February 2023 by Kituo Cha Sheria and Haki Jamii Rights Centre, representing two organisations, twelve individual petitioners, and the memory of one woman: Lucy Wambui Ng’ang’a.
Lucy was a mother of three. In August 2019, without her family’s knowledge, she was recruited for domestic work in Saudi Arabia. Within three days of arriving, she was deported and rerouted to Iraq. In December 2019, she called her brother to say she was safe and would be home the following year. Eight days later, a stranger called to say she had died in Baghdad. She died on 22 December 2020. The cause of her death has never been explained. Her body has never been brought home because her family could not raise the USD 7,000 the government asked them to pay for repatriation.
The other petitioners are women who made it back, but carry the evidence of what they survived: confiscated passports, withheld wages, physical and sexual abuse, confinement, starvation. They had tried the embassy. They had tried the recruitment agency. They had called the Ministry of Labour. They had largely been ignored.
“The returnees continue to face the same challenges that pushed them to go out of the country upon return.” Judgment, para 118(d)
Their testimonies form the factual backbone of a case that the court ultimately found proved on a balance of probabilities. The State did not seriously contest what had happened to these women. It simply argued it had done enough.
What Made This Possible: The Kafala System
To understand why migrant domestic workers from Kenya are so vulnerable in the Middle East, it helps to understand the Kafala sponsorship system.
Under Kafala, a migrant worker’s legal right to remain in the destination country is tied entirely to their employer. The employer, known as a kafeel, covers the worker’s recruitment fees, visa and travel costs, and in return holds near-absolute authority over them. The worker cannot change jobs, leave the country, or seek help without the kafeel’s consent. In practice, this means employers routinely confiscate passports on arrival, knowing that a worker without documents cannot leave. If a worker escapes abuse and seeks help, she risks becoming an undocumented immigrant and facing detention or deportation.
The system was described in the petition as a modern form of slavery. The court agreed that its operation was made possible, partly by the State’s failure to put proper safeguards in place before women departed Kenya. This amounted to a violation of the right to freedom from slavery and servitude under Article 30 of the Constitution.
The court also found that Kenya’s own immigration system had compounded the problem: workers are issued 90-day visit visas even when their employment contracts run for two years. When those visas expire, workers automatically become undocumented. This is a fact the Ministry of Immigration was aware of, and did nothing to address.
ISLA’s Role: What We Argued
ISLA and FIDA Kenya were admitted as amici curiae, a mechanism that allows organisations with relevant expertise to submit legal analysis to a court without being a party to the case. Our role was to situate the petition within the broader international and regional legal framework on trafficking, women’s rights, and labour migration.
Our submissions addressed four core areas:
The gendered nature of labour migration. Domestic work is feminised work. The majority of Kenyan labour migrants to the Middle East are women, and their concentration in domestic work (an unregulated, isolated, and highly informal sector) is not accidental. It reflects global patterns of gender inequality in which care work is undervalued, under-protected, and overwhelmingly performed by women of colour from the Global South. Understanding the abuse these women face requires understanding this structural context.
State obligations under international law. We drew the court’s attention to Kenya’s obligations under the Palermo Protocol on trafficking, CEDAW, the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights, the Maputo Protocol, and the Vienna Convention on Consular Relations, all of which impose positive duties on the State to prevent trafficking, protect survivors, and provide consular assistance to nationals in distress abroad.
Trafficking as indirect discrimination against women. ISLA argued that the State’s failure to address the structural conditions that make women vulnerable to trafficking. This is inclusive of inadequate pre-departure training, weak regulation of recruitment agencies, and the absence of safe houses and functional embassy support, which constitutes indirect discrimination on the basis of sex and is inconsistent with Kenya’s obligations under CEDAW and the Maputo Protocol.
Comparative protections in other jurisdictions. We provided the court with analysis of how jurisdictions including South Africa, Canada, Singapore and Hong Kong regulate the protection of domestic workers, offering a framework for what meaningful State protection could look like.
What the Court Decided
The State broke its own law. The court’s central finding is deceptively straightforward: Kenya’s Employment Act already provides a comprehensive legal framework to protect migrant workers. Sections 82 to 85 require that before a foreign employment contract is signed off by a labour officer, the officer must be satisfied that the worker has given their informed consent, that there is no fraud or misrepresentation, and that the contract complies with the law. Section 84 requires employers or their agents to post a security bond, a form of financial guarantee to cover costs like repatriation in the event something goes wrong.
None of this was being enforced. Labour officers were attesting contracts without verifying consent. Bonds were not being required. Workers were being sent abroad under contracts they had never seen, to jobs that bore no resemblance to what they had been promised. The court found that this laxity had directly enabled the Kafala system’s hold over Kenyan workers and that the State was responsible for the consequences.
Key Orders Issued
Declarations of violation. The court declared that the petitioners were entitled to effective State protection against trafficking, slavery, and abuse, and that the State’s failures violated their rights to life, human dignity, freedom from slavery, information and fair labour practices.
Fresh vetting of recruitment agencies. All local employment recruitment agencies must be immediately re-vetted, jointly by the 1st to 5th respondents.
Security bond enforcement. The Ministry of Labour and related agencies were ordered to enforce the section 84 bond requirement for all future foreign employment contracts in the Middle East.
Repatriation of Lucy Wambui Ng’ang’a’s remains. The court ordered the 3rd respondent (Ministry of Foreign Affairs) to repatriate her body at State expense within three months of judgment, finding that requiring her family to fund this cost was itself a violation of their dignity arising from the State’s own failure.
Referral to the Attorney-General. The judgment was ordered transmitted to the AG’s office for consideration of a comprehensive labour migration law and policy, and to the Kenya National Human Rights Commission for follow-up on unexplained migrant worker deaths.
What The Court Did Not Do
The court declined to order a suspension of labour migration to the Middle East, finding fresh vetting a more proportional response. It also declined to award compensation to the petitioners for the trauma, loss, and suffering they endured. The court instead gave a finding that the declarations and structural orders were sufficient to vindicate their rights. ISLA notes this decision with concern: declaratory relief, however significant, does not meet the immediate material and psychosocial needs of women who survived trafficking and sexual violence. We believe the door remains open to further litigation and advocacy to secure individualised reparation for survivors.
Why This Matters Beyond Kenya
Labour migration from Africa to the Gulf and wider Middle East is not a uniquely Kenyan story. Women from Uganda, Ethiopia, Tanzania, Ghana, Nigeria and across the continent migrate for domestic work under similar conditions and face similar vulnerabilities. The legal and structural failures the court identified in Kenya- inadequate regulation of recruitment agencies, weak bilateral labour agreements, no safe houses, unresponsive embassies, and no reintegration support on return are replicated across sending States on the continent.
What makes this judgment significant regionally is its insistence that the State cannot hide behind the absence of new legislation. The court’s finding that non-enforcement of existing law is itself a constitutional violation gives litigators and advocates in other jurisdictions a useful framework for holding their own governments accountable without waiting for legislative reform.
The court’s use of Kaunda v President of the Republic of South Africa, a case involving South Africa’s duty to protect its citizens facing human rights abuses abroad, to ground Kenya’s extraterritorial obligations to its migrant workers is also of wider relevance, and is consistent with the African Commission’s developing jurisprudence on State responsibility for the conduct of non-State actors.
“For the Government to knowingly permit its citizens to leave the country either voluntarily or forcefully to face cruel, inhuman and degrading treatment abroad would be an abdication on the part of the Government of its obligation under Article 21(1) of the Constitution.” — Justice Odunga, cited in the judgment.
ISLA’s Broader Work on Women’s Socio-Economic Rights
This case sits within ISLA’s Women’s Socio-Economic Rights (WSER) thematic area, which addresses the structural economic conditions that keep women in poverty, insecurity, and vulnerability, including in the labour market. Across the continent, women’s socio-economic rights are undermined by legal frameworks that exclude domestic workers from labour protections, welfare systems that leave returning migrants without support, and migration governance systems that prioritise economic diplomacy over the rights of the workers they send abroad.
ISLA’s approach in cases like E038/2023 is to bring the international and regional human rights framework to bear on these structural failures, thereby surfacing the gendered dimensions of seemingly neutral legal and policy choices, and demanding that courts and governments account for them. Our amicus submission in this case was informed by years of engagement with feminist jurisprudence on trafficking, care work, and the feminisation of poverty, and by the lived experiences of the women whose testimony made this case possible.
Through the Feminist Litigation Network, ISLA continues to build the capacity of feminist litigators across Africa to bring these arguments, and these women’s realities into the courts that have the power to change them.