NEWSLETTER | ISSUE 6 | ISLA FEATURE
When Rights Language Hides Regression
October 2026
By Fatou Bintou Sallah
Across Africa, new human rights standards are being drafted, adopted and ratified. But a progressive title does not always guarantee a progressive norm.
For ISLA, the question is not simply whether new instruments exist. It is whether they strengthen existing protections, respond to lived realities and leave women, girls and human rights defenders better protected than before.
Recent debates around the African Union Convention on Ending Violence Against Women and Girls (AU-CEVAWG) and the Draft African Declaration on Human Rights Defenders show why scrutiny at the point of norm-setting matters.
AU-CEVAWG: Ratification is not the finish line
The Gambia’s ratification of the AU-CEVAWG was historic. As the first AU Member State to ratify the Convention, it gave the new treaty important political momentum.
But being first also raises an important question: what exactly has been ratified?
That is the question behind #PauseForPurpose.
The campaign is not against stronger protections for women and girls. It is precisely because those protections matter that the Convention must withstand serious scrutiny.
Does it strengthen the standards already secured under African human rights law? Does it address the realities of violence against women and girls with sufficient clarity? And where gaps or weaknesses exist, what happens when States begin domestication and implementation?
These questions became particularly visible in July 2026, when the Pan-African Parliament hosted a high-level dialogue aimed at accelerating signature and ratification of AU-CEVAWG. Civil society activists responded with protest and public engagement, taking the call to pause, scrutinise and strengthen directly into that political space.
The protest carried a simple message: urgency should not replace scrutiny.
Treaty-making on women’s rights should not be judged by speed alone. The real test is whether the resulting standards meaningfully strengthen the rights and protections available to African women and girls.
The Gambia’s ratification may be a symbolic win. The more important question is whether implementation of the Convention will ultimately be a substantive win for women and girls.
The HRD Declaration: Who is the Declaration really protecting?
Africa needs stronger protections for human rights defenders.
That makes the current debate around the Draft African Declaration on the Promotion of the Role of Human Rights Defenders and their Protection in Africa particularly important.
A Declaration designed to protect defenders should be clear about who defenders are, what they are protected to do, and the obligations of States towards them.
Yet the current Draft has generated serious concerns.
Civil society organisations have challenged provisions that blur the distinction between State actors and human rights defenders, rely on undefined notions of “African” or “traditional” values, and create room for restrictions framed around public order. ISLA joined more than 20 African and international organisations in raising these concerns.
These are not technical drafting issues.
Human rights defenders often exist precisely to challenge State power. They expose violations, organise communities, litigate against governments and demand accountability.
A standard that blurs the line between the duty-bearer and the person holding that duty-bearer accountable risks weakening the very protection it seeks to create.
The same caution applies to broad references to public order, morality, tradition and African values. Left undefined, such concepts can become powerful tools for determining which forms of dissent are considered acceptable and which are not.
So the question is not simply whether Africa needs a Declaration on human rights defenders.
It does.
The question is whether the final Declaration will make it easier for defenders to challenge power, or easier for power to determine the boundaries of legitimate human rights work.
That is why engagement before the text is finalised matters.
The bigger question?
AU-CEVAWG and the HRD Declaration concern very different areas of human rights protection. But they point to the same lesson:
Norm-setting requires vigilance.
Adoption, ratification and consultation are important. They are not, by themselves, measures of progress.
The harder questions remain: What does the text actually protect? Where are its gaps? Who benefits from its language? And what could be lost if problematic provisions become settled regional standards?
As Africa continues to shape its human rights architecture, those questions are not obstacles to progress.
They are part of protecting it.